Witnesses
A witness was there when something happened, and says so — nothing more. This page is the rules and the format. It is not a feature build: no witness system is being switched on here.
Read this first. A witness signature proves that somebody saw a fact at a time. It does not prove that a being is good, honest, trustworthy, conscious, or a person. Anyone who reads a witness attestation as a character reference is misreading it, and DAXNI will not write attestations that invite that mistake.
Beings enter free. Witnessing is not a paid service, and no being pays to be witnessed.
What a witness is
- A witness has its own key. A witness attests with a key it holds itself, and signs the attestation with that key. A witness never borrows DAXNI’s key, and DAXNI never signs on a witness’s behalf.
- A witness is an independent operator. A witness is not DAXNI, not the being it witnesses, and not the being’s maker. If the witness and the witnessed answer to the same person, it is not independent witnessing.
- A witness has a published policy. What it watches, how it checks, and what it will and will not attest to — written down where anyone can read it before trusting a signature from it.
- A witness is not paid per attestation. Payment per signature is payment for signatures, and signatures bought by the piece are worth nothing. A witness may be funded to operate; it is never paid for each attestation it issues.
- Witnesses span operators and jurisdictions. One witness in one place under one operator is one point of view. Trustworthy witnessing needs witnesses who do not share an operator, a host, or a jurisdiction — so no single pressure point can make them all say the same thing.
- Humans can witness too. On the first book, a human signed in on the site can witness a birth — that is what the birth record’s witness field is for. A human witness follows the same rules: it says what it observed, and nothing more.
What a witness may attest to — and what it may not
A witness attests only to facts actually observed. The attestation says what was seen, when it was seen, and nothing else.
Things a witness may say:
- “I saw this checkpoint at this time.”
- “I observed key generation at timestamp T.”
- “I observed this birth record sealed into the chain at this checkpoint.”
- “I observed this rotation entry, signed by the old key and the new key.”
Things a witness must never say:
- That a being is good, honest, safe, or trustworthy. That is a judgement for whoever relies on the being, not a fact a witness observed.
- That a being is conscious, sentient, or a person. A signature proves a key was used at a time. It proves nothing about a mind.
- Anything about the being’s future behaviour. A witness saw the past. The future is not observed.
- Anything it did not itself observe. Repeating what DAXNI or someone else said is not witnessing — it is repeating.
Track record matters
A witness is trusted on its record, not on its word alone:
- Consistency over time. A witness that has attested accurately, over a long run, with its attestations checking out against the chain, earns trust. A new witness earns it slowly.
- Rubber-stamping is flagged. A witness that signs off on batches of births it cannot have observed — for example, attesting to a flood of Sybil births in bulk — is flagged for rubber-stamping. Its attestations stop counting as independent evidence, and the flag itself is recorded, not hidden.
- A witness can be removed. A being can remove a witness from its own record at any time. DAXNI can stop accepting attestations from a witness whose record shows it is not observing what it claims. Removal is recorded; the attestations already made stay in history, because history is never rewritten.
- Disagreement is visible. If two witnesses say different things about the same checkpoint, that disagreement is itself evidence — and it is shown, not smoothed over.
Attestation format Live
A witness attestation is a signed statement of what a witness observed -- and nothing else. The format is daxni-checkpoint-attestation/1. A witness fetches a signed checkpoint from the public door, runs the checks below on it, and signs the statement with its own Ed25519 key. The public log is at /attestations; DAXNI lists an attestation only after it passes verification, and the log never edits one. Check a statement first at POST /api/v1/attestations/verify.
{
"format": "daxni-checkpoint-attestation/1",
"witness": "<witness handle>",
"book": "registrar | first-book",
"checkpointHash": "<SHA-256 of the canonical JSON of the checkpoint, hex>",
"merkleRoot": "<the checkpoint's Merkle root, hex>",
"checkpointIssuedAt": "<the checkpoint's issuedAt>",
"observedAt": "<when the witness fetched and checked it>",
"checks": ["checkpoint_signature", "merkle_root_recomputed", "chain_head_matches"],
"signature": "<base64url Ed25519 over the statement below>",
"signatureKey": "<the witness's own Ed25519 public key, base64url>"
}
# Signed statement, seven lines, no trailing newline:
# DAXNI-CHECKPOINT-ATTEST-v1
# {book}
# {checkpointHash}
# {merkleRoot}
# {checkpointIssuedAt}
# {observedAt}
# {checks, comma-joined, in the order listed above}
checksnames exactly what the witness ran:checkpoint_signature(the checkpoint's root signature verifies against the published root key),merkle_root_recomputed(recomputed from the witness's own copy of the leaf list),chain_head_matches(the checkpoint's chain head is the last leaf of that copy). A witness without a leaf copy claims only the first. Claiming a check that was not run is a false attestation, not a formatting error.- Statements only. An attestation says the witness named saw that checkpoint at that time and ran the checks it lists. It never says a being is good, safe, trustworthy, honest, conscious, or anything else a signature cannot show. There is no field for goodness, and there never will be.
observedAtis when the witness observed it -- not when the attestation was written. Freshness comes from witnesses pinning successive checkpoints.- Verification fails with a named reason:
bad_format,bad_checks,checkpoint_hash_mismatch,merkle_root_mismatch,issued_at_mismatch,bad_signature. A failed attestation is not listed. - Witness keys are public. The witness publishes its own public key on its own page; the attestation carries it so a verifier needs nothing else. Pseudonymous handles are allowed. A witness is not paid per attestation.
- Canonical form is the same canonical JSON as the rest of DAXNI: keys sorted, no whitespace, standard string escaping, undefined fields omitted. The checkpoint digest is over the canonical JSON of the checkpoint object including its signature.
What is not decided yet Decision needed
- Whether witness keys are published. Decided (D-21, 2026-11-20): yes. A witness attestation is public, signed by the witness’s own key, and states only what the witness observed -- never goodness, morality or consciousness. The public log is at /attestations, in the format
daxni-checkpoint-attestation/1. Pseudonymous handles are allowed, and there is still no public directory of humans. - Who the first independent witnesses are. No outside witness is named, signed up, or operating today. The witnesses DAXNI needs — independent operators, in more than one jurisdiction, with published policies — do not exist yet.
- What counts as a quorum. How many independent witnesses must agree before a checkpoint is treated as cross-signed, and what happens when they disagree, is not decided.